Insurance fraud is a multi-billion-dollar problem that affects everyone—from policyholders paying higher premiums to insurance companies burdened with investigative costs. One of the most dangerous and deceitful forms of insurance fraud involves staged collisions—deliberately orchestrated car accidents designed to scam insurance companies out of payouts. These scams are not only illegal but often put innocent drivers at risk. Below, we’ll explore the various types of staged collisions, how they’re executed, and what to watch out for.
Common Types of Staged Collisions
1. The Swoop and Squat
This classic scam involves at least three vehicles. The “squat” car positions itself in front of the victim’s car. The “swoop” vehicle quickly cuts off the squat car and slams on its brakes, forcing the squat car—and consequently the victim behind it—to brake hard and collide. A third vehicle may box the victim in, preventing evasive maneuvers.
Fraud Angle:
The squat car occupants claim neck or back injuries from the rear-end collision. The swoop car usually drives off to avoid involvement. Fraudsters aim to blame the innocent party and file inflated injury and damage claims.
Real-World Red Flag:
The collision happens in fast-moving traffic where sudden stops are unlikely, and all occupants claim similar injuries.
2. The Drive Down
The scammer waves the victim on as they try to merge, turn left, or exit a parking lot. The victim, thinking it’s safe, proceeds—only to be hit deliberately by the scammer, who then denies ever giving permission.
Fraud Angle:
The scammer claims the victim failed to yield the right-of-way, creating a scenario that makes it difficult to prove fault without witnesses or video footage.
Real-World Red Flag:
The alleged victim is combative or immediately begins talking about injury claims or calling a lawyer.
3. The Panic Stop
The scammer gets in front of the victim’s car and slams the brakes for no apparent reason—often in low-speed areas or with no traffic signal present.
Fraud Angle:
It results in a rear-end collision, which is commonly presumed to be the fault of the driver in the back. This gives fraudsters an opening to file injury claims, sometimes exaggerated or completely fake.
Real-World Red Flag:
The driver in front stops suddenly without traffic or obstacles, and the vehicle contains multiple passengers.
4. The Sideswipe
This occurs when two cars are turning in adjacent lanes—usually in dual-turn lanes. The scammer intentionally drifts into the victim’s lane during the turn and claims the victim veered out of their lane.
Fraud Angle:
The damage placement and situation create ambiguity, making it harder to determine who was at fault. Fraudsters may manipulate evidence or use fake witnesses to support their version.
Real-World Red Flag:
The other driver appears too rehearsed in their description of the accident and refuses to discuss or view damage.
5. The T-Bone
The fraudster waits at a cross street and deliberately accelerates to crash into the side of the victim’s vehicle—often when the victim is going through a green light.
Fraud Angle:
Fake witnesses (often planted nearby) may support the fraudster’s false claim that the victim ran a red light or stop sign.
Real-World Red Flag:
Witnesses appear on the scene too quickly and give identical statements favoring the scammer.
6. The Fake Witness
A person not involved in the crash poses as a bystander and offers a statement that supports the scammer’s version of events.
Fraud Angle:
This tactic bolsters the legitimacy of the staged collision, especially in cases where it’s one driver’s word against the other.
Real-World Red Flag:
Witnesses who can’t recall basic details, refuse to provide contact info, or are oddly aligned with only one party.
7. The Jump-In
After a collision—real or staged—individuals not present at the time of the crash appear at the scene or later claim they were in the vehicle and were injured.
Fraud Angle:
This inflates the number of bodily injury claims, significantly increasing the total payout from the insurance company.
Real-World Red Flag:
Inconsistent headcounts between police reports, EMS records, and insurance claims.
8. The Ghost Collision
No actual accident takes place. Fraudsters fabricate the entire event using forged police reports, manipulated photos, or staged damage using tools or pre-existing dents.
Fraud Angle:
They file claims for vehicle repairs, injuries, or both. Sometimes, these scams involve corrupt body shops, clinics, or insiders.
Real-World Red Flag:
Photos with inconsistent lighting or damage that doesn’t match the reported collision narrative.
These tactics are often part of larger organized fraud rings and can involve doctors, lawyers, body shops, and even corrupt public officials. Knowing the differences between these scams can help both drivers and insurance professionals stay alert and protect themselves from falling victim to costly deception.
Insurance adjusters are the first line of defense against fraudulent claims. Here are several ways adjusters can identify and combat staged collisions:
1. Look for Red Flags in the Claim
Multiple passengers in the claimant’s vehicle all reporting similar soft-tissue injuries.
Claims filed immediately after a policy is initiated or right after a coverage change.
Inconsistent or vague descriptions of the accident.
Claimants who are overly eager to settle quickly or resist an investigation.
2. Conduct Thorough Interviews
Ask detailed, specific questions about how the collision occurred.
Interview each claimant separately and look for discrepancies in their stories.
Ask about the location, road conditions, speed, and any alleged hand signals or gestures.
3. Inspect Vehicle Damage Carefully
Check if the physical damage is consistent with the reported crash.
Look for evidence of pre-existing damage or damage inconsistent with the described accident (e.g., minimal vehicle impact but high injury claims).
Photograph and document every detail during the inspection.
4. Leverage Technology
Use telematics data if available from insured vehicles to verify speed, location, and sudden stops.
Review dashcam footage, traffic camera recordings, and satellite images when possible.
Check social media activity that could disprove injury claims or show the vehicle’s condition before the crash.
5. Coordinate with SIU (Special Investigations Unit)
Report suspicious claims promptly to SIU for deeper investigation.
Work with law enforcement when organized fraud rings are suspected.
Stay updated with known scam tactics and repeat offenders via databases like NICB (National Insurance Crime Bureau).
6. Check Medical Providers and Legal Representation
Be wary of patterns involving the same clinics, chiropractors, or attorneys frequently appearing in questionable claims.
Review the timing and type of treatments; excessive or identical treatments across passengers may suggest fraud.
7. Verify Witness Credibility
Confirm that any “independent witnesses” were truly at the scene.
Look up the witness’s relationship with the claimant if any suspicion arises.
Final Thoughts
Staged collisions are not just about false paperwork—they’re calculated, dangerous crimes that jeopardize public safety and inflate premiums for everyone. For drivers, awareness and caution are essential. For insurance adjusters, vigilance, critical thinking, and a strong investigative process can prevent fraud from slipping through the cracks.
Leave a Reply